hucong 8a671a109c [CI][Cherry-pick] Relax TTFT benefits threshold from 0.4 to 0.5 to account for DP load imbalance (#8684)
Cherry-pick https://github.com/vllm-project/vllm-ascend/pull/8683

### What this PR does / why we need it?

This PR relaxes the TTFT threshold from `0.4` to `0.5` to improve
robustness under Data Parallel (DP) load imbalance.

#### Background

The current assertion enforces: prefix75 < prefix0 * 0.4

####  Nightly Failure Cases (Observed)

| prefix0 | threshold (0.4x) | prefix75 | delta |
|--------|------------------|----------|--------|
| 4696.24 | 1878.50 | 1883.99 | +5.49 |
| 4696.20 | 1878.48 | 1896.01 | +17.53 |
| 4636.73 | 1854.69 | 1902.48 | +47.79 |
| 4655.17 | 1862.07 | 1913.54 | +51.47 |
| 4685.35 | 1874.14 | 1919.36 | +45.22 |
| 4660.33 | 1864.13 | 1915.41 | +51.28 |
| 4648.30 | 1859.32 | 1950.50 | +91.18 |
| 4655.30 | 1862.12 | 1962.32 | +100.20 |

---

####  Nightly Passing Cases (Observed)

| prefix0 | threshold (0.4x) | prefix75 | margin |
|--------|------------------|----------|---------|
| 4685.64 | 1874.26 | 1864.46 | -9.80 |
| 5520.28 | 2208.11 | 1928.97 | -279.14 |
| 4639.23 | 1855.69 | 1846.86 | -8.83 |
| 4651.64 | 1860.66 | 1854.30 | -6.36 |
| 4640.39 | 1856.15 | 1840.32 | -15.83 |
| 4677.20 | 1870.88 | 1848.35 | -22.53 |
---

#### Key Observations

- Failures exceed the threshold by only **~5 ms to ~100 ms (~0.3%–5%)**
- Passing cases often have **very tight margins (~5–10 ms)**
- There is clear **overlap between pass and fail boundaries**
- Many failures are **borderline violations**, not real regressions

---

#### Root Cause

The instability is caused by **Data Parallel (DP) load imbalance**,
which introduces systematic variance:

- Uneven request distribution across workers  
- Queueing delays  
- Increased TTFT variance (especially for `prefix75`)

---

#### Conclusion

- The current threshold (`0.4x`) is **too strict**
- Observed natural fluctuation:
  - Absolute: up to ~100 ms  
  - Relative: up to ~5% over threshold  
- Pass/fail boundary is currently **too sensitive to runtime jitter**

---

#### Change

We relax the threshold: **0.4 → 0.5**


This adjustment:

- Accounts for expected runtime variance  
- Reduces false negatives  
- Maintains a meaningful performance constraint  

Even with `0.5`, the requirement remains strict (`prefix75 < 50% of
prefix0`) and does not mask real regressions.


---

### Does this PR introduce _any_ user-facing change?

No.

This change only affects internal test assertions and does not impact
user-facing behavior or model performance.


---

### How was this patch tested?

- Verified against existing TTFT test cases:
  - Previously failing cases (due to small variance) now pass
  - No regressions observed in other scenarios
- Confirmed that failures were due to DP load imbalance rather than
actual performance degradation
- Ensured the updated threshold still enforces a meaningful constraint
on TTFT

Signed-off-by: underfituu <hzhucong@163.com>
2026-04-27 16:38:07 +08:00
2026-04-21 19:49:06 +08:00
2025-02-05 10:53:12 +08:00
2026-01-12 11:21:31 +08:00
2025-01-29 02:44:13 -08:00

vllm-ascend

vLLM Ascend Plugin

DeepWiki

| About Ascend | Documentation | #SIG-Ascend | Users Forum | Weekly Meeting |

English | 中文


Latest News 🔥

  • [2026/02] We released the new official version v0.13.0! Please follow the official guide to start using vLLM Ascend Plugin on Ascend.
  • [2025/12] We released the new official version v0.11.0! Please follow the official guide to start using vLLM Ascend Plugin on Ascend.
  • [2025/09] We released the new official version v0.9.1! Please follow the official guide to start deploying large-scale Expert Parallelism (EP) on Ascend.
  • [2025/08] We hosted the vLLM Beijing Meetup with vLLM and Tencent! Please find the meetup slides here.
  • [2025/06] User stories page is now live! It kicks off with LLaMA-Factory/verl/TRL/GPUStack to demonstrate how vLLM Ascend assists Ascend users in enhancing their experience across fine-tuning, evaluation, reinforcement learning (RL), and deployment scenarios.
  • [2025/06] Contributors page is now live! All contributions deserve to be recorded, thanks for all contributors.
  • [2025/05] We've released the first official version v0.7.3! We collaborated with the vLLM community to publish a blog post sharing our practice: Introducing vLLM Hardware Plugin, Best Practice from Ascend NPU.
  • [2025/03] We hosted the vLLM Beijing Meetup with vLLM team! Please find the meetup slides here.
  • [2025/02] vLLM community officially created vllm-project/vllm-ascend repo for running vLLM seamlessly on the Ascend NPU.
  • [2024/12] We are working with the vLLM community to support [RFC]: Hardware pluggable.

Overview

vLLM Ascend (vllm-ascend) is a community maintained hardware plugin for running vLLM seamlessly on the Ascend NPU.

It is the recommended approach for supporting the Ascend backend within the vLLM community. It adheres to the principles outlined in the [RFC]: Hardware pluggable, providing a hardware-pluggable interface that decouples the integration of the Ascend NPU with vLLM.

By using vLLM Ascend plugin, popular open-source models, including Transformer-like, Mixture-of-Experts (MoE), Embedding, Multi-modal LLMs can run seamlessly on the Ascend NPU.

Prerequisites

  • Hardware: Atlas 800I A2 Inference series, Atlas A2 Training series, Atlas 800I A3 Inference series, Atlas A3 Training series, Atlas 300I Duo (Experimental)
  • OS: Linux
  • Software:
    • Python >= 3.10, < 3.12
    • CANN == 8.5.0 (Ascend HDK version refers to here)
    • PyTorch == 2.9.0, torch-npu == 2.9.0
    • vLLM (the same version as vllm-ascend)

Getting Started

Please use the following recommended versions to get started quickly:

Version Release type Doc
v0.17.0rc1 Latest release candidate See QuickStart and Installation for more details
v0.13.0 Latest stable version See QuickStart and Installation for more details

Contributing

See CONTRIBUTING for more details, which is a step-by-step guide to help you set up the development environment, build and test.

We welcome and value any contributions and collaborations:

Branch

vllm-ascend has a main branch and a dev branch.

  • main: main branch, corresponds to the vLLM main branch, and is continuously monitored for quality through Ascend CI.
  • releases/vX.Y.Z: development branch, created alongside new releases of vLLM. For example, releases/v0.13.0 is the dev branch for vLLM v0.13.0 version.

Below are the maintained branches:

Branch Status Note
main Maintained CI commitment for vLLM main branch and vLLM v0.17.0 tag
v0.7.1-dev Unmaintained Only doc fixes are allowed
v0.7.3-dev Maintained CI commitment for vLLM 0.7.3 version, only bug fixes are allowed, and no new release tags anymore.
v0.9.1-dev Maintained CI commitment for vLLM 0.9.1 version
v0.11.0-dev Maintained CI commitment for vLLM 0.11.0 version
releases/v0.13.0 Maintained CI commitment for vLLM 0.13.0 version
rfc/feature-name Maintained Feature branches for collaboration

Please refer to Versioning policy for more details.

Weekly Meeting

License

Apache License 2.0, as found in the LICENSE file.

Description
XC-LLM: A Specially Optimized LLM Inference Engine for ModelHub XC
Readme Apache-2.0 33 MiB
Languages
C++ 51.3%
Python 46.3%
CMake 1%
Shell 0.7%
C 0.5%