{
  "status": "VALIDATION_SELECTION_LOCKED_BEFORE_FRESH_TEST",
  "locked_at": "2026-07-15T20:37:11+09:00",
  "selection_metric": "open_weight_panel_mean_prompt_worst_vs_base",
  "tie_break": "candidate_id lexical order",
  "selected_by_method": {
    "dpo": {
      "candidate_id": "dpo_b",
      "validation_primary": 0.40625,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.3837890625,
        0.427734375
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "dpo_a",
        "dpo_b"
      ]
    },
    "ht_mnpo_helpfulness": {
      "candidate_id": "ht_help_b",
      "validation_primary": 0.4072265625,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.3828125,
        0.4296875
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "ht_help_b"
      ]
    },
    "ht_mnpo_safety": {
      "candidate_id": "ht_safety_a",
      "validation_primary": 0.4150390625,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.3925537109375,
        0.4384765625
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "ht_safety_a",
        "ht_safety_b"
      ]
    },
    "inpo_avg": {
      "candidate_id": "inpo_b",
      "validation_primary": 0.40625,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.3818359375,
        0.427734375
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "inpo_b"
      ]
    },
    "ronpo_full_expect": {
      "candidate_id": "ronpo_full_a",
      "validation_primary": 0.4033203125,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.37890625,
        0.42580566406249987
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "ronpo_full_a",
        "ronpo_full_b"
      ]
    },
    "ronpo_k_only": {
      "candidate_id": "ronpo_top_a",
      "validation_primary": 0.412109375,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.3876953125,
        0.43557128906249987
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "ronpo_top_a"
      ]
    },
    "sppo_avg": {
      "candidate_id": "sppo_b",
      "validation_primary": 0.4111328125,
      "validation_primary_ci95": [
        0.3866943359375,
        0.4345703125
      ],
      "eligible_candidates": [
        "sppo_b"
      ]
    }
  },
  "selected_ronpo_overall": "ronpo_top_a",
  "failed_methods": [
    "ht_mnpo_conciseness",
    "ipo",
    "simpo"
  ],
  "panel_summary_sha256": "8850f23e16cadf56a99e3d562d224ce5337ab36fa588d8a843382853e6ad17bd",
  "evaluator_lock_sha256": "ab7b12c84932ed57acfec7edbcbc1ff1df5e9acd203869b1458343adf6e5b2c8",
  "grid_sha256": "abfd982ef10c3bc71364752241150286ebf06be5e97f087596adf80e55d459e0",
  "fresh_test_opened": false,
  "spent_sealed_split_touched": false
}