diff --git a/docs/CCCL_ENGINEX_ARCHITECTURE_ALIGNMENT.md b/docs/CCCL_ENGINEX_ARCHITECTURE_ALIGNMENT.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c178f567 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/CCCL_ENGINEX_ARCHITECTURE_ALIGNMENT.md @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +# CCCL ↔ EngineX Architecture Alignment + +## Executive Summary + +EngineX ships precompiled `.so` kernels — **zero `.cu` source files** are available. +The optimization surface is Python runtime params + Triton JIT kernels. + +CCCL's value is NOT parameter values. It's the **architectural patterns** that +tell us which parameters matter, what their constraints are, and why. + +## Three-Layer Architecture Mapping + +### CCCL Layer → EngineX Layer → What We Control + +| CCCL | EngineX | Controllable? | +|------|---------|--------------| +| `dispatch_reduce.cuh` (GridEvenShare work distribution) | `paged_attn.py` (V1/V2 dispatch, _PARTITION_SIZE) | **Yes** — Python runtime | +| `kernel_reduce.cuh` (kernel entry, atomic vs 2-phase) | `_C_flashattention.so` (paged_attention_v1/v2) | **No** — precompiled | +| `agent_reduce.cuh` (tile consumption, vectorized load) | internal to `.so` | **No** — precompiled | +| `tuning_reduce.cuh` (policy_selector) | `_custom_ops.py` (SMEM=49152) | **Partially** — SMEM limit | +| `dispatch_transform.cuh` (spread_out_items_per_thread) | `rmsnorm_kernels.py` (BLOCK_SIZE heuristic) | **Yes** — Triton autotune | +| `kernel_scan.cuh` (lookback/lookahead) | `prefix_prefill.py` (BLOCK_M/N, num_warps) | **Yes** — Triton config | +| `dispatch_scan.cuh` (tile init + scan kernel) | `triton_splitk.py` (split-K attention) | **Yes** — Triton config | + +### Key CCCL Patterns We Apply + +1. **GridEvenShare** (`grid_even_share.cuh`): + - `max_blocks = sm_occupancy × sm_count × subscription_factor` + - BI-V100: 1 × 16 × 5 = 80 max CTAs + - Applied to: `paged_attn.py` _BI100_TARGET_TILES, V1/V2 threshold + +2. **Compound Reduce** (`summary_statistics.cu`): + - Accumulator = struct{m, l, o} (max, sum_exp, weighted_output) + - unary_op: score_tile → partial softmax stats + - binary_op: online softmax merge with correction factor + - Applied to: `_forward_decode_pytorch` online softmax loop + +3. **Two-Phase Reduce** (`kernel_reduce.cuh`): + - Phase 1: each CTA reduces a partition → `d_block_reductions[blockIdx.x]` + - Phase 2: single CTA reduces all block results + - Applied to: paged_attention_v2 partition → merge + +4. **spread_out_items_per_thread** (`dispatch_transform.cuh`): + - Reduce items/thread when there aren't enough items to fill all SMs + - `items = min(max, ceil_div(N, sm_count × threads × occupancy))` + - Applied to: Triton kernel BLOCK_SIZE selection + +5. **Lookback Delay** (`tuning_scan.cuh`): + - 16 SMs → ~32 concurrent CTAs → tile_state fits in 6MB L2 + - Inter-CTA contention near zero → no_delay optimal + - Applied to: scan-based operations (softmax denominator) + +## BI-V100 Hardware Profile (Confirmed) + +| Property | Value | Impact | +|----------|-------|--------| +| SM count | 16 | 3.1x fewer CTAs than spec (50) → larger tiles per CTA | +| SMEM | 48KB | Same as NVIDIA → CCCL SMEM constraints apply directly | +| HBM BW | 900 GB/s | BW/SM = 56 GB/s ≈ B200 level → bytes_in_flight = 64KB | +| L2 cache | 6MB | 8.3x smaller than SM100 → faster coherence, no_delay wins | +| Warp size | 32 | Same as NVIDIA → CCCL warp-level primitives work | + +## Files Inventory + +### Precompiled (CANNOT modify) +- `_C_flashattention.so` — paged_attention_v1, paged_attention_v2, reshape_and_cache +- `_C.so` — xformers attention backends +- `libtriton.so` — Triton compiler/runtime + +### Triton JIT (CAN modify) +- `pkgs/triton/ops/flash_attention.py` — Flash Attention (head_dim ≤ 128 only) +- `pkgs/xformers/ops/fmha/triton_splitk.py` — Split-K attention (V2 pattern) +- `pkgs/xformers/ops/triton/rmsnorm_kernels.py` — RMSNorm +- `pkgs/xformers/ops/triton/rope_padded_kernels.py` — RoPE + +### Python runtime (CAN modify) +- `paged_attn.py` — V1/V2 dispatch, _PARTITION_SIZE, decode fallback +- `prefix_prefill.py` — Prefill attention BLOCK_M/N/NUM_WARPS +- `vllm/_custom_ops.py` — SMEM=49152 (already fixed from 32768) +- `computility-run.yaml` — Server launch params